J.K. Rowling has been taking some serious heat for her essay in which she makes controversial remarks about “trangenderism”. I would usually come springing to her defense, but she’s a straight Satanist. She can go about her demonic civil war on her own.
“Transgender women are women. Any statement to the contrary erases the identity and dignity of transgender people and goes against all advice given by professional health care associations…”
“… who have far more expertise on this subject matter than either [Rowling] or I,” writes Daniel Radcliffe — the actor who played Rowling’s character Harry Potter — distancing himself from the elaborate essay J.K. Rowling published yesterday.
Radcliffe’s statement is fascinating, because it stands so clearly apart from any interest in pursuing truth. The statement has 3 parts:
1. “Transgender women are women.” This is a slogan, as simple and absolute as you can get. You could say it more elaborately: In my book, in my way of living, the word “women” will always be understood to include transgender women. To put it like that would be to make it more obvious that Radcliffe is actively involved in creating the culture that he wants to become pervasive, but to stick to the simple form, the slogan, is to perform creatively. It is effective. Daniel Radcliffe communicates that this is what we, the good people, are saying.
Part 2: “Any statement to the contrary erases the identity and dignity of transgender people.” This is a warning. Failure to get inside the performance of the idea that we are making pervasive within the culture is hurting people. Don’t say anything inconsistent with “Transgender women are women” or you are doing something harmful. You might imagine that it’s worthwhile to speak openly about many different ideas or that searching for “the truth” is healthy and valuable, but you’re doing damage along the way, and you shouldn’t want that. Daniel Radcliffe doesn’t want to hurt people.
Part 3: “Any statement to the contrary… goes against all advice given by professional health care associations who have far more expertise on this subject matter than either [Rowling] or I.” There are experts, but they’re not offering expertise on the subject of whether “Transgender women are women.” That’s beside the point. The expertise is on the subject of what will be helpful for people who have a health care issue, and these experts are saying that what we ought to do is manifest belief that “Transgender women are women.” All other forms of expression are in defiance of the advice about what needs to be done to be helpful to people with a health care issue, and Daniel Radcliffe doesn’t want to be that sort of person. He wants you to know that. Posted by Ann Althouse at 7:29 AM